On Nov. 3 this site argued that the Los Angeles Lakers were right to keep Jake LaRavia in the starting lineup ahead of Ziaire Williams, and it named the number that would change the answer: “If his three-point percentage stays above 40 into December while LaRavia’s rebounding and defense fade, the job should go back to Williams.” The case against Williams was that his shooting was a mirage — “four games of shooting he has never sustained before,” set against 34.2 percent across 119 games in Brooklyn, a baseline quoted here from that piece.
Half of that test has returned a result, and it went against this site. Williams is 20-of-44 from three, 45.5 percent, across 11 games and 260 minutes, including 10-of-23 in the six games since that piece ran. The job has not moved. The reason given for why it shouldn’t has.
The Four-Game Sample Is Now an Eleven-Game One
The Nov. 3 argument rested on sample size: “Taking a 46.7 percent start as his true level means betting against five years of evidence.” Two hundred and sixty minutes is no longer a start, and the percentage has barely moved off 46.7.
Williams is averaging 10.5 points on 56.8 percent shooting for the season, and 10.3 points in 21.8 minutes across the six games since. His best night was 17 points on 4-of-8 from three in 21 minutes off the bench at the Detroit Pistons on Nov. 8, a game Luka Dončić missed. He has stayed exactly the catch-and-shoot threat he described himself as in early November.
Jake LaRavia Kept the Job on the Glass, Not the Scoreboard
The condition’s second half required LaRavia’s rebounding and defense to fade. The rebounding did the opposite: 3.6 boards a game through Nov. 3, 4.3 across the six games since, with offensive rebounds up from 1.4 to 2.7. In Milwaukee on Nov. 11 he pulled down nine rebounds, seven of them offensive, and scored nothing on 0-of-4 shooting.
His steals have dropped sharply, from 1.7 a game to 0.7. His blocks have not: 1.0 before and 0.7 since, and he put up three of them in Phoenix on Sunday. Either way, those two columns do not settle whether a defender is holding up, and the part of the condition that can be measured cleanly — the rebounding — moved the wrong way for Williams.
LaRavia’s offense did slump across that stretch: 12-of-31 from the field, 38.7 percent, and 6.2 points a game. But 12 points on 4-of-10 shooting in Phoenix was his best scoring night since Oct. 31, which is the first evidence in three weeks that the shooting half of his case is not simply gone.
Williams is still outscoring the starter in fewer minutes. The Nov. 3 piece framed this as sustainable skills against unsustainable shooting. Close to the reverse happened — the shooter kept shooting, the non-shooter mostly stopped scoring — and LaRavia is still starting because of the one thing that piece treated as his floor: “They’re starting him for his rebounding and defensive range.”
The Comparison This Was Supposed to Settle Never Got Made
Williams has started once since, at the Atlanta Hawks on Nov. 9, and that was not a promotion. Austin Reaves was out ill and Quentin Grimes was out with a right finger sprain, so JJ Redick started Williams alongside LaRavia rather than in place of him. Two nights later in Milwaukee, with Reaves back, Williams returned to the bench and LaRavia made his ninth consecutive start.
Sunday settled the last version of that question. Reaves was out again at the Phoenix Suns and Williams still did not start: LaRavia started and played 32 minutes, while Williams got 19 off the bench. A starter’s absence no longer moves this lineup, which is its own answer.
Retire the Reasoning, Keep the Call
The Nov. 3 verdict holds and its argument should be thrown out. The bet was that Williams’ shooting would disappear, and across 11 games and 260 minutes it has not. The honest case for LaRavia is the one the piece filed as secondary: he is the only forward in the rotation who rebounds, and the Lakers never fixed that hole.
That also means the escape hatch is gone. Because the condition was written as a conjunction, Williams now needs only one thing — LaRavia’s rebounding slipping back toward 3.5 — and there is no shooting-regression argument left to fall back on. At 12-2 with eight straight wins, Redick has no reason to go looking for that change. He should know it is one cold rebounding week away.
All box-score figures compiled from ESPN game summaries for each of the Los Angeles Lakers’ 14 games this season, covering 11 Ziaire Williams appearances and 13 Jake LaRavia appearances through Nov. 15. Starting lineups and inactives from the same summaries. Williams’ Brooklyn baseline as quoted in this site’s Nov. 3 piece.







Leave a Reply