There’s a comfortable story about the 2000–2002 Lakers: Shaquille O’Neal bullied the paint for three quarters, then handed the ball to Kobe Bryant to finish. Half of that story is right. The other half has hardened into myth, and the myth flatters the guard.
What the record actually says about the closing minutes
Start with the case against the headline you probably wanted to read, because it’s real. Game 4 of the 2000 Finals in Indianapolis went to overtime, and with 2:33 left in the extra period — the Lakers ahead by three — O’Neal fouled out. A 21-year-old Bryant took the game from there, hitting a pair of jumpers and then tipping in a miss with 5.9 seconds left to seal a 120-118 win. He finished the overtime with eight points on 4-of-5 shooting.
And the closing minutes weren’t the only place Bryant had outgrown the sidekick label. In the 2001 postseason he averaged 29.4 points, 7.3 rebounds and 6.1 assists as the Lakers went 15-1 — production sitting just behind O’Neal’s 30.4 and 15.4 rather than in a different tier altogether. If the argument is that Bryant was a 1B and not a No. 2, that is the honest version of it, and pretending it doesn’t exist would be dishonest.
Why “closer” is the wrong award to be handing out
Here’s the problem with resting a legacy on those minutes: they’re a sliver of the game, and O’Neal owned everything before them. In 1999-00 he averaged 29.7 points, 13.6 rebounds and 3.8 assists, and won his first MVP, his first Finals MVP and his first championship — the same season he became just the third player in NBA history to earn MVP honors for the regular season, All-Star Game (shared with Tim Duncan) and Finals in one year.
The Finals ledger isn’t close. O’Neal was named Finals MVP following all three of the Lakers championships, becoming the only player besides Michael Jordan to win the award three consecutive times — a distinction that still stands. He did it against elite resistance: in the 2001 Finals he averaged 33 points on 57.3% shooting against Dikembe Mutombo, who won Defensive Player of the Year that season.
The internal Lakers hierarchy reflected all of it. During the championship runs, O’Neal was named All-NBA First Team each year, with Bryant named to the All-NBA Second Team twice and the All-NBA First Team once.
The Bottom Line
The strongest objection to crowning O’Neal is the one this piece led with: when the Lakers needed a bucket in the last three minutes, the ball found Bryant, and Bryant delivered — Game 4 in 2000 is the proof that won’t go away. If “clutch” means only those possessions, the guard has the better claim.
But that definition quietly does the work of the myth. It takes the smallest, most telegenic slice of a game and lets it stand in for the whole. Across three Finals, the most valuable Laker was the man who was unguardable for 40 minutes and forced the double-teams that freed everyone else — including the closer. O’Neal was the engine; Bryant was the finish. The finish is what people remember, which is exactly why it’s the part that gets overrated.
Leave a Reply